Pension lump sum or monthly payments?
If your employer offers a lump sum in place of a lifetime pension, this comparison shows what return the lump sum would need to earn to match the pension, and how that depends on how long you live.
Your pension offer
Return needed to match the pension to 88
3.2%
annual return the lump sum must earn to pay the same income
Value of the pension at 5.0%
$402,029
vs. $500,000 lump sum, to age 88
Break-even age
Age 103
when pension payments are worth more than the lump sum (at 5.0%)
If you took the lump sum and withdrew the same income
At 5.0%, the lump sum would still have money left at age 95. Actual returns vary from year to year, and a lump sum carries market risk the pension does not.
How long you live changes the answer
| If you live to | Return needed | Pension value at 5.0% |
|---|---|---|
| 75 | -4.8% | $230,148 |
| 80 | 0.1% | $309,368 |
| 85 | 2.4% | $371,438 |
| 90 | 3.6% | $420,073 |
| 95 | 4.4% | $458,179 |
| 100 | 4.8% | $488,036 |
How this works
The tool values the pension's monthly payments, including any cost-of-living increases, from the start age to the planning life expectancy. The "return needed" is the annual rate at which the present value of those payments equals the lump-sum offer. The break-even age is when the pension payments, discounted at your assumed return, become worth more than the lump sum. The chart shows the lump sum invested at a constant return while withdrawing the same income.
Important disclosures
Results are hypothetical estimates for educational and illustrative purposes only. They do not reflect actual investment results, are not guarantees of future results, and are not investment, tax, legal, or Social Security claiming advice or a recommendation of any strategy or product. Tax figures use 2026 federal and New Jersey rules as we understand them, which change over time.
This is an educational comparison, not a recommendation to take or decline a lump sum or to roll over a retirement plan. It does not consider survivor (joint) pension options, the financial strength of the plan or Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation limits, taxes, investment fees, market volatility, health, other income, or the value of guaranteed lifetime income. Lump-sum and rollover decisions are generally irreversible.
Your inputs stay in your browser and are not sent to us, unless you are signed in to the client portal and choose to save them to your planning profile. Ramion Capital is not currently accepting clients pending regulatory approval. Consult qualified tax, legal, and financial professionals about your situation.