Why the order of returns matters in retirement
Two retirees can earn exactly the same returns over 30 years and end up in very different places. This illustration shows how withdrawals make the timing of good and bad years matter.
Assumptions
Returns are a hypothetical set generated to match the average and volatility above — not historical returns or a forecast. Every scenario uses exactly the same returns, only in a different order.
Good years first
$2,627,570
after 30 years
Bad years first
Runs out in year 11
same returns, different order
With no withdrawals
$4,754,898
identical in every order
Portfolio value by year
Summary
| Scenario | Balance after 10 years | After 30 years | Money lasts |
|---|---|---|---|
| Good years first | $4,685,110 | $2,627,570 | 30+ years |
| Same return every year (5.3%) | $935,628 | $0 | 29 years |
| Bad years first | $61,687 | $0 | 11 years |
Average return 6.0% (compound 5.3%); best year 31.3%, worst year -13.0%.
How this works
The tool generates one hypothetical set of annual returns with your chosen average and volatility, then runs the same withdrawals through three orderings: the best years first, the worst years first, and a steady return equal to the set's compound average. Withdrawals are taken at the start of each year and rise with inflation.
Important disclosures
Results are hypothetical estimates for educational and illustrative purposes only. They do not reflect actual investment results, are not guarantees of future results, and are not investment, tax, legal, or Social Security claiming advice or a recommendation of any strategy or product. Tax figures use 2026 federal and New Jersey rules as we understand them, which change over time.
The return set is hypothetical, not historical, and is sorted to show extremes; real markets will not follow either ordering. The illustration ignores taxes, fees, and changes in spending, and is not a forecast or a recommendation of any investment strategy.
Your inputs stay in your browser and are not sent to us, unless you are signed in to the client portal and choose to save them to your planning profile. Ramion Capital is not currently accepting clients pending regulatory approval. Consult qualified tax, legal, and financial professionals about your situation.