Which accounts should you draw from first?
The order in which you tap taxable, tax-deferred, and Roth accounts can change your lifetime taxes and what you leave behind. Compare four common approaches.
Your situation
Lowest lifetime taxes
Proportional from all
$155,432
Largest after-tax legacy
IRA → taxable → Roth
$1,406,228
Difference in lifetime taxes
$49,775
between the highest- and lowest-tax orders
Strategy comparison
| Withdrawal order | Lifetime taxes | Money lasts | Ending balance | After-tax legacy |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Taxable → IRA → Roth | $205,207 | past 95 | $1.4M | $1,258,393 |
| IRA → taxable → Roth | $182,166 | past 95 | $1.4M | $1,406,228 |
| Proportional from all | $155,432 | past 95 | $1.5M | $1,377,580 |
| Fill bracket from IRA (convert extra to Roth) | $179,835 | past 95 | $1.3M | $1,334,623 |
After-tax legacy counts Roth and taxable accounts at full value (heirs generally receive a step-up in basis) and the IRA after your heirs' tax rate.
Total savings by age
Taxes paid each year
How this works
Each year, the tool withdraws enough to cover your after-tax spending, net of Social Security and pension income, following each strategy's order. Required minimum distributions are taken from the IRA when they apply. Federal tax includes taxable Social Security, the standard and senior deductions, and capital gains on the taxable account's gain share; New Jersey tax includes the retirement income exclusion. Taxes are paid from the withdrawals.
The bracket-fill strategy withdraws from the IRA up to the top of the chosen bracket each year, uses it toward spending, and converts any excess to the Roth IRA.
Important disclosures
Results are hypothetical estimates for educational and illustrative purposes only. They do not reflect actual investment results, are not guarantees of future results, and are not investment, tax, legal, or Social Security claiming advice or a recommendation of any strategy or product. Tax figures use 2026 federal and New Jersey rules as we understand them, which change over time.
Deterministic estimate in today's dollars with a constant real return; it does not model market volatility, annual taxation of dividends and interest in the taxable account, Medicare IRMAA surcharges, the death of a spouse and the switch to single filing, state taxes other than New Jersey, or future changes in tax law (the senior deduction is scheduled to expire after 2028 but is held constant here). It is not a recommendation of any withdrawal strategy.
Sources: IRS Rev. Proc. 2025-32; P.L. 119-21; IRC §86; IRS Uniform Lifetime Table; NJ Division of Taxation.
Your inputs stay in your browser and are not sent to us, unless you are signed in to the client portal and choose to save them to your planning profile. Ramion Capital is not currently accepting clients pending regulatory approval. Consult qualified tax, legal, and financial professionals about your situation.